Born in North York, Ontario, David Spaner grew up in Vancouver where he graduated from Langara College and Simon Fraser University. During his stint as a movie reviewer for The Province newspaper he published Dreaming in the Rain: How Vancouver Became Hollywood North by Northwest (Arsenal 2003 $19.95). It was followed by Shoot It! Hollywood Inc. and the Rising of Independent Film (Arsenal 2011) which "examines the Hollywood studio system from the early days when it produced more quality yet commercially viable films, to today, when studios seem only interested in surefire sequels and comic-book adaptations aimed at a global audience. By the same token, Shoot It! also celebrates today's great movies produced outside of the studio system, chronicling the international independent film movement in seven countries (the United States, Canada, Mexico, Britain, France, Romania, and South Korea), from its roots to the revolutionary impact of digital technology. It also features commentary from indie film notables such as Mike Leigh, Gus Van Sant, Claire Denis, Miranda July, Woody Allen, Atom Egoyan, Catherine Breillat, and more."

In 2021, Spaner published a behind-the-scenes book about the Solidarity resistance movement, Solidarity: Canada's Unknown Revolution of 1983 (Ronsdale $21.95) documenting the event using intimate storytelling and melding cultural and rebel politics to provide insight into the conflicts that are still with us. It was the largest political protest in the province's history and threatened to end in an all-out general strike.

BOOKS:

Dreaming in the Rain: How Vancouver Became Hollywood North by Northwest (Arsenal 2003) 1-55152-129-6 $19.95

Shoot It! (Arsenal 2011) 978-1-55152-408-5 $22.95

Solidarity: Canada’s Unknown Revolution of 1983 (Ronsdale, 2021) $21.95 978-1-55380-638-7

Keefer Street (Ronsdale, 2024) $24.95 9781553807209

[Photo: Yvonne De Carlo]

[BCBW 2024] "Film"

***

Solidarity: Canada’s Unknown Revolution of 1983
by David Spaner (Ronsdale $21.95)

Review by Rod Mickleburgh (BCBW 2022)

On a single, unforgettable day in B.C.—July 7, 1983—26 government bills came down the chute striking at the very heart of longstanding union and societal rights. Oversight of human rights, tenant rights, employment standards and more was abolished. Government employees had their contract gutted and all public sector employers in the province were given the power to fire employees without cause.

It was truly a revolution of the right wing.

People fought back with a revolution of their own. Under the banner of Operation Solidarity, occupations and record large protest marches took place across the province. When nothing changed, there was job action that brought B.C. to the verge of an all-out general strike.

Despite these dramatic events, nothing of any depth has been written about it, beyond labour historian Bryan Palmer’s useful but overly-partisan book, Solidarity: The Rise and and Fall of an Opposition in British Columbia (New Star, 1987) published 35 years ago, and last year’s Tranquille & Battle for Community Care in B.C. (Nightwood 2020) by the late Gary Steeves on the three-week occupation of the Tranquille residential facility in Kamloops.
Solidarity: Canada’s Unknown Revolution of 1983 is a welcome addition to the surprisingly thin library of books on one of the largest, most broad-based political protests in Canadian history. Over four turbulent months in the summer and fall of 1983, hundreds of thousands of British Columbians were caught up in the massive fightback against the wave of repressive legislation brought in by Premier Bill Bennett’s freshly-elected Social Credit government.

Solidarity is far from a comprehensive history. That remains to be written. Rather, David Spaner focuses on the non-union partner of Operation Solidarity, the Solidarity Coalition. There is comparatively little about unions and the labour movement, which, after all, co-founded and co-funded Operation Solidarity with the Coalition, as well as providing the picket line muscle that started the uprising down the path to a general strike. There are background bios of many of the activists featured in the book, giving it a folksy feel, but not much about Coalition leaders Renate Shearer, Father Jim Roberts and the fascinating history of BC Federation of Labour president, Art Kube who also headed Operation Solidarity.

Concentrating on the Coalition, where Spaner’s sympathies lie, is not a bad thing. Largely ignored by a media that concentrated on a “what next?” mentality, it’s a story that cries out to be told. But the result is an incomplete, somewhat one-sided account.

The Coalition was the broad-based organization of community advocates, activists and social movements that drove the fight on social issues. Stretching into every nook and cranny of the province, they represented the heart and soul of Operation Solidarity, giving it credibility and proof that it was more than a self-interested crusade by unions. The welding of these two disparate groups—the inspired brainchild of Art Kube—was unprecedented. Operation Solidarity would never have been the force it was without the Coalition.

It is refreshing to revisit those heady times through the eyes of those who threw themselves into the Coalition. Spaner provides good descriptions of the endless organizing, unwieldy but respectful marathon meetings, and grassroots decision-making that went on. The chapter on feminism and the strong role played by women in the fightback is particularly good. “It brought all those people together in such a short period of time,” participant and now speaker of the Legislature, Raj Chouhan tells the author. “It was quite a phenomenon, you know, like when you saw people from the faith groups, socialist types, or women’s rights, suddenly together.” They galvanized many British Columbians to join a protest for the first time in their lives.

But at times, the book loses focus by drifting off into quirky tangents such as socialist history going back to the First International, tales of old lefties, endearing though they are, musical memories from Vancouver’s past and tales of Barkerville and Wells. There are also errors. It was the Fraser River gold rush that prompted establishment of the Colony of British Columbia in 1858, not the 1860s gold rush at Barkerville. There are others, none fatal.

In the end, it mostly came to nought. With 70,000 public sector workers already on the picket line, ferry workers and bus drivers were due to walk out the following Monday morning. By then, however, the government had backed down on its anti-union bills and Operation Solidarity leaders wanted out. With Kube sidelined by pneumonia, International Woodworkers of America (IWA) leader, Jack Munro flew to Kelowna to negotiate a deal with Premier Bill Bennett. Solidarity’s Coalition partners were frozen out. It was now a union show. Late Sunday night, November 13, as the province held its breath, Munro and Bennett announced the strike was over. The so-called Kelowna Accord contained nothing that addressed social issues.

Left in the dark back in Vancouver, members of the Coalition, many of whom had put their personal lives on hold for months, were devastated. Spaner gives them justifiable voice. “We were all in tears,” recounts tireless social justice advocate Patsy George. “It was a horrible betrayal.” Self-styled “hoarder of records” Sara Diamond was so upset she threw out all her records from Solidarity and the Coalition.

Despite the ennobling harmony of the summer, the gap between unions and social groups proved too wide to be bridged. Spaner puts all the blame on the labour side, disparaging what he calls “obsolete unionism.” It’s an odd term for what was the most militant labour movement in Canada, reflecting an imperfect understanding of how unions work. The Coalition’s vote for a general strike to be carried out by unions, not Coalition members, irritated many in the private sector.

Munro, who unleashed a barrage of disparaging remarks of his own about members of the Coalition, takes his lumps, including withering criticism from then BC Teachers’ Federation president Larry Kuehn, one of Solidarity’s heroes for leading 30,000 teachers out on an illegal strike, as the first wave of Solidarity’s general strike.

Despite its faults, we should be grateful that David Spaner has given us this account. His book reminds us that there was a time when British Columbians united in common resolve to stand up for justice and human rights, and anything, even the political surrender of a government, seemed possible. Spaner is right to conclude: “The Solidarity uprising of 1983 gave us a glimpse of what could be. [It] was far greater than its anticlimactic ending.”
Such a time it was. 978-1-55380-638-7

Rod Mickleburgh co-authored with Geoff Meggs, The Art of the Impossible: Dave Barrett & the NDP in Power, 1972-1975 (Harbour). It won the Hubert Evans Prize in 2013.

***
Keefer Street by David Spaner (Ronsdale Press $24.95).


Review by Grant Buday (BCBW 2024)


For a good introduction to 1930s Vancouver, pick up a copy of David Spaner’s novel, Keefer Street. It follows the life and times of Jake Feldman, a Jewish kid growing up in the neighbourhood of Strathcona, home to people of Chinese, Irish and Jewish descent.


The young Jake is interested in baseball and shooting pool, but the hard times soon politicize him. It is, after all, the “Dirty Thirties” when most countries around the world entered into deep recessions. By 1931, unemployment reached 28 percent in British Columbia — the highest in Canada. Thousands of unemployed men went to rural BC work camps, including Jake. These make-work programs didn’t pan out.


While employed at a government relief camp, Jake joins a protest over the lousy wages where two weeks of moving dirt earns him less than two dollars.


He falls in with a group of his fellow dissatisfied workers. “We unveil a black and yellow banner: Relieve the Relief Campers. Workers Not Beggars,” Jake recounts. He and 208 others soon find themselves in Oakalla Prison for the night. His life as an activist has begun. He also reads Theodore Dreiser’s Sister Carrie, about the sweatshops of Chicago. In Germany, Hitler is on the rise.


Jake’s youth is counterpointed by chapters set in 1986 at the fifty-year reunion of the “Mac-Paps” in Spain. The Mackenzie-Papineau Battalion was the Canadian contingent of volunteers who went to fight General Franco and fascism in the years 1936 to 1939. The Mac-Paps were named after William Lyon Mackenzie and Louis-Joseph Papineau. Mackenzie led a revolution against something called the Family Compact in Toronto in 1837; Papineau did the same in Montreal. The Family Compact was a group who were thought to be preventing democracy from flourishing by keeping control of land and politics to themselves.


Jake’s early years are the most dramatic in Keefer Street. For example, when the Nazi warship, Karlsruhe, docks at the Ballantyne Pier in March 1935, Jake joins a mass protest. The range of the people standing against the Nazis in Vancouver is fascinating.


David Spaner sets the scene: “The waterfront is decorated in banners: Relief Camp Workers Against Fascism, One Big Union, Finnish Organization of Canada, International Typographical Union, Red International, Railway Carmen, Communist Party, Chinese Unemployed Association, Anti-Nazi Coalition, Mayday Committee, Pacific Coast Fishermen’s Union, Co-operative Commonwealth Federation, Ukrainian Anti-Fascist League, Waterfront Workers Association, Order of Sleeping Car Porters, Hotel and Restaurant Employees Union, Jewish Workers Circle.”


In one of the book’s most intense incidents, Jake and others board the Karlsruhe and a battle ensues. Fighting his way to the prow he burns the Nazi flag before getting punched out and waking up in jail for the second time.


Such scenes as this, as well as the book’s cover, which shows a man with his right fist defiantly raised, implies that Keefer Street is a novel about war and protest. Yet it’s not until halfway through that Jake sets off for Spain’s civil war, and the novel is nearly finished before we see any action—he gets shot in the leg and is tended in the hospital by an American nurse named Rebecca.


When Jake returns to Vancouver, he finds himself blackballed for having volunteered in support of the Spanish Civil War’s Republican cause and can’t find work. In fact, he can’t even volunteer for the Canadian Forces to return to Europe for World War II.


His personal life is just as disheartening. Lena, with whom he’d been in love, has gone to Toronto. Jake’s friends who stayed home are thriving. His father, who abandoned the family some years earlier and returned to the fictional northern town of Fort Harold, is running a successful clothing store and is involved with a new woman. What’s Jake going to do? For a while he contemplates changing his name to Jack Fields to skirt the antisemitism he feels is holding him back. As for his interest in politics, it seems to have faded and he has no particular desire to do anything else other than shoot the occasional game of pool. Eventually he marries Polly, an old friend, and when his father dies they move to Fort Harold, take over the store and raise three kids. The decades pass. Yet Polly, an aspiring actress, is bored. She finally takes the kids and leaves for Los Angeles; when Jake eventually follows, she says it’s over.


Keefer Street is solidly written and full of interesting historical detail. The depiction of Jewish life and the links with family members in Toronto and New York give the impression of a strong and pervasive ethnic interconnectedness.


The bright spot in Jake’s otherwise bleak life is his reunion with Rebecca, the nurse who tended him when he was recovering from his gunshot wound in 1936. Rebecca is still politically active. They visit a Spanish hospital where she is invited to give a talk. “When Rebecca is called to the microphone, it is the first time I’ve heard her speak in public and I’m taken by her eloquence and her manner,” says Jake. “Talking with her hands as much as her voice, in Spanish as much as in English, she tells of the urgent needs for medical supplies in Nicaragua, likening its conditions, under bombs and bullets, to Spain.”


Even fifty years later, she’s fighting the good fight. Jake finds strength in this. He and Rebecca connect and fall for each other. In the final scene they are in British Columbia together on serene and bucolic Hornby Island.


“Rebecca and I turn onto a dirt road to a cottage on the water, set in a garden of fern, bramble, violet.

“And we rest.”  9781553807209


Grant Buday’s historical fiction novels, Orphans of Empire (Brindle & Glass, 2020) and In the Belly of the Sphinx (Brindle & Glass, 2023) tell of the late 19th century lives of settlers in Vancouver and Victoria respectively.